In October 2022, a resident of Mariinsk imported a 2020 KIA Mohave from South Korea, declared a value of USD 15,600 (about RUB 960,000) and paid duties, while Vladivostok customs decided the car was worth more, presented a screenshot from a website with archived sales where a similar SUV was valued at USD 34,000, and charged an additional RUB 375,000 in duties plus penalties — more than RUB 750,000 in total.
The court found two errors: a 2020 car was compared with a 2021 car — these are not identical goods, and the price on the website was not final, since delivery, clearance and auction fees could be added to it.
What it means for importers
A screenshot is not indisputable evidence, and customs must prove that the declared value is inaccurate, not just show a price from a website. The model year matters: comparison with a car of a different year is grounds for refusing an additional charge. The price on a website is not equal to the final transaction price.
What it means for your calculation
For the calculation of a shipment, this is a matter of customs value: duties and VAT (НДС) depend on the price. If customs adjusts the value based on a screenshot of someone else's sale, check whether the goods are comparable in model year, trim and transaction terms. Differences in these parameters are an argument against an additional charge, and a price difference between customs declarations (ДТ) by itself does not prove that the transaction price is unjustified.