Calcuta Calcuta
Customs Customs

Resin is not resin: why customs lost a dispute over chemical raw material value

The Moscow Arbitration Court ruled illegal a customs value adjustment for a resin batch imported by Pigment JSC from China: customs increased the value by RUB 437,831, comparing the goods with a different resin.

1 min read Source: Disputes with Customs

The Moscow Arbitration Court ruled illegal a customs value adjustment for a resin batch imported by Pigment JSC from China: customs increased the value by RUB 437,831.13 and charged additional duty and VAT (НДС) totaling RUB 121,717.06, while the company purchased 20 tonnes of polyamide-epichlorohydrin resin for its own production at a price of CNY 4.30 per kilogram, EXW Weifang delivery terms.

Customs did not accept the declared value and compared the goods with polyamidoamine-epichlorohydrin resin from another declaration. The court found such a comparison incorrect, primarily because customs did not take into account the characteristics of the raw material: the solids content in Pigment's resin was 20.1–20.2%, while the comparable indicator of the goods from the reference declaration was not specified in the customs decision, and the court accepted explanations about differences in production technology and costs. In its assessment, the compared resins were not homogeneous: a similar name of the chemical product was not enough.

There was also a problem with the comparison period: the disputed customs declaration (ДТ) was registered in July 2025, while customs used a declaration from January 2024, and the court pointed to a violation of the time limits.

What it means for your calculation

For the calculation of a shipment, this is a matter of customs value: duties and VAT (НДС) depend on the price. If customs adjusts the value based on another declaration, check whether the goods are comparable in characteristics (content, technology), volume and delivery dates. A similar product name is not enough — homogeneous goods are needed, and a price difference between declarations (ДТ) by itself does not prove that the transaction price is unjustified.

Source: Disputes with Customs

← All posts

Report a bug
Report a bug

You can submit a bug report after registration — that way we can clarify the details and let you know when it is fixed.