The National Financial Market Council (NSFR, НСФР) sent feedback to the Ministry of Digital Development (Минцифры), the Ministry of Finance (Минфин) and the Bank of Russia (ЦБ РФ) on the third package of government measures to combat fraud, "Antifraud 3.0". Bankers oppose legislatively fixing a list of situations in which a citizen can consent to the processing of personal data, and instead propose describing situations in which processing is prohibited, leaving the decision to the citizen in all other cases.
The head of the NSFR, Andrey Emelin, believes that the list will become an obstacle in risk assessment, refining banking offers for clients and bringing new financial products to market.
Another point criticized by bankers is the ban on using aggregators for SMS notifications to clients. In its current form, the bill obliges banks to conclude direct contracts with each telecom operator or pay their operator extra for aggregation. The NSFR proposes keeping the option to use aggregators while tightening their regulation. The Ministry of Digital Development responds that the measure is aimed at increasing the transparency of mailings and reducing fraud risks. According to Timur Aitov, head of the financial security commission of the Chamber of Commerce and Industry of Russia, for a bank with 10 million messages per month, the loss of an aggregator discount of RUB 1–2 per message would result in RUB 10–20 million in additional expenses monthly. At the same time, Aitov acknowledges that aggregators blur responsibility for the content of mailings and are used in fraudulent schemes, but considers the effect of the new restrictions asymmetrical: costs are measurable, while the gain in security is not.
The third disputed point is the use of the Unified Identification and Authentication System (ESIA, ЕСИА) as the only method of remote simplified identification when issuing a bank card. The NSFR fears a sharp increase in the load on ESIA and failures during peak periods, up to complete unavailability. As an alternative, the council proposes additional procedures that reduce the risk of abuse: the use of bank and operator IDs, verification of the taxpayer identification number (INN, ИНН) and insurance number (SNILS, СНИЛС), and verification of physical possession of the device. The Ministry of Digital Development clarifies that the draft does not provide for a general ban on remote identification by all methods, but only reduces them when issuing an electronic means of payment. Timur Aitov adds that ESIA is a monolithic entry point, and if it is left as the only one, banks lose the ability to distribute load and manage service degradation.
The Ministry of Digital Development confirmed receipt of the NSFR letter and said that the appeal would be comprehensively reviewed and worked out with interested departments; no timeline was specified. The ministry also noted that most of the proposals are outside its competence and will be considered by relevant departments (CNews).
What it means for your calculation: the bill has not yet entered into force and is under discussion, so there are no direct changes to the calculation of duty, fees or delivery. If the restrictions on remote identification and SMS mailings are adopted, banks may pass the new costs on to clients through fees, and the issuance of bank cards and payments for importers will become longer and more complicated.