Calcuta Calcuta
Logistics Logistics

Supreme Court: freight forwarder liable for cargo even if a third-party driver carried it

The Supreme Court overturned decisions by three instances that recovered almost RUB 3 million for missing cargo from the carrier, not the forwarder: under Article 805 of the Civil Code (ГК РФ), engaging a third party does not remove liability.

1 min read Source: TsentrVED

The Supreme Court clarified when a freight forwarder is liable for missing cargo itself, even if a third-party carrier transported it. The dispute concerned cargo worth almost RUB 3 million, Supreme Court of the Russian Federation ruling No. 305-ЭС26-1806 in case No. А40-231517/2024.

Individual entrepreneur Lyubov Petrovskaya entered into a freight forwarding contract with SmartParts LLC: delivery of cargo from Dzerzhinsky to Yessentuki. The company undertook to provide a serviceable vehicle and deliver the cargo to the recipient, and for this purpose engaged a third-party carrier, agreed on the driver, and passed the customer's details about him and the vehicle to the customer. The cargo was handed to this driver but did not reach Yessentuki; the driver stopped responding. The customer filed a police report, sent the forwarder a claim, and then filed a lawsuit to recover almost RUB 3 million in losses.

Three court instances refused the claim. In their view, the forwarder performed only certain functions of the consignor, and the party that actually carried the cargo was liable for its loss.

The Supreme Court disagreed with that approach. The forwarder itself undertook the obligation to deliver the cargo, itself organized the carriage, itself agreed on the driver and communicated his details, vehicle number to the customer. Engaging a third party does not release it from liability to the client; this follows directly from Article 805 of the Civil Code. The court did not take the name of the contract into account: the decision was based on its terms and the actual actions of the parties — who undertook to deliver the cargo, who chose the carrier, how the carriage was arranged. Agreeing on the carrier with the customer after the contract was concluded did not remove the obligations.

The decisions of the lower instances were overturned and the case was sent for a new hearing. The almost RUB 3 million was not recovered by this ruling.

Source: TsentrVED

← All posts

Report a bug
Report a bug

You can submit a bug report after registration — that way we can clarify the details and let you know when it is fixed.