One of the frequent grounds for a decision on inconsistency of the declared customs value is comparison with the customs value of identical or homogeneous goods. The mere availability of information about deals with other goods does not make the declared customs value unreliable: the customs authority must justify the applicability of the corresponding method and the comparability of the compared deals with the terms of the declarant's deal.
Why such decisions arise
Customs usually indicates the number of the target customs declaration for goods by which it carried out the comparison, and concludes that the declared price is inconsistent. The key question in defense is whether the goods under the target customs declaration are indeed identical or homogeneous compared with the declared ones, and whether the terms of the deals are comparable.
How to check the target customs declaration
Information on release under the target customs declaration can be obtained free of charge through the personal account of a foreign-trade participant of the Federal Customs Service of Russia:
- Copy the number of the target customs declaration from the decision on amending the customs value.
- Log in to the personal account of a foreign-trade participant with the right to submit documents.
- Go to the section "Reference information / Provision of information on release of goods".
- Create a request, specifying the number of the customs declaration, the number of the goods item under the declaration and the quantity of goods in kilograms.
- Submit the request and receive a reply with information on release under the target customs declaration.
How to prepare objections
Compare characteristics: purpose of the goods, physical characteristics, material, completeness, terms of delivery, country of origin and other parameters. If the target goods differ in key characteristics or the terms of the deals are incomparable, this may be grounds for recognizing the decision on adjustment as unlawful.
Prepare the evidence base: contract, invoice, terms of delivery, commercial letters, price calculation, technical description of the goods. A foreign-trade participant has 3 months from the date of receiving the corresponding decision to appeal a decision on amending the customs value.
Glossary
- Identical goods — goods identical in all respects, including physical characteristics, quality and reputation on the market.
- Homogeneous goods — goods not identical in all respects but having similar characteristics and performing the same functions, commercially interchangeable.
- Target customs declaration — the declaration for goods selected by the customs authority for comparison when applying the method by transaction value of identical or homogeneous goods.
- Adjustment of customs value (KTS) — change of the declared customs value and additional assessment of customs payments by decision of the customs authority.