Calcuta Calcuta
Useful reads

Court: an LLC's money is not the owner's money

The Arbitration Court of the Ural District ruled: compensating a director's personal warehouse and his business-card purchases counts as income. The company owed 1.9 million rubles of personal income tax; the dispute reached cassation.

3 min read Source: Vremya bukhgaltera

The Arbitration Court of the Ural District on September 17, 2026 upheld the decision to assess additional personal income tax to the director and sole founder of LLC "Bioproject": 1,901,897 rubles of tax and 11,886.85 rubles of penalty under Article 123 of the Tax Code. The dispute concerned two flows of money from the company to a person — "compensations" of 12.96 million rubles and purchases on a business card of 843,572.43 rubles. The court recognized both as income, from which the company as tax agent was obliged to withhold tax.

The first story looks almost decent. In December 2019 the director and the company signed an agreement: the employee uses his non-residential premises as a warehouse, the employer pays compensation of 270,000 rubles a month. In 2023 the director was transferred 12,960,000 rubles. During the audit of the 6-NDFL calculation for 2023 the inspection treated these payments as wages, and the courts of three instances agreed. The reason is Article 188 of the Labor Code: it speaks of tools, personal transport, equipment and materials, and non-residential premises are not on this list. There is an agreement, there are signatures. But. Therefore the "compensation" does not fall under the exemption; it is ordinary income.

The second story is simpler and cruder. In 2023, 843,572.43 rubles of purchases unrelated to the LLC's activity were paid with the company's business cards: "Master Vin" — 39 thousand, "Pyaterochka" — 7.8 thousand, "Matur" in Nagayevo — 12 thousand, shops in Sochi, including Gussi and Hugo Boss — 369 thousand, the watch shop AIITimme.ru — 207 thousand, restaurants — 5.6 thousand, pet shops — 676 rubles. No advance reports or receipts explaining these expenses as needs of the warehouse or office were found either during the audit or in court. The rule here is old: unconfirmed accountable amounts are income of an individual, and personal income tax is paid on them.

The company tried to save the 12.96 million rubles retroactively. Already after the audit, on December 9, 2024, an agreement on novation appeared: the employee's debt to the company turned into a loan until December 31, 2030. The court looked at the date, at the absence of new conditions and called it an abuse of right. No new obligation arose, so the tax is not cancelled either.

What could have been done. Pay salary and withhold personal income tax from it, pay dividends — also with tax, issue a loan under an agreement, issue money on account for business needs and require an advance report with receipts. A purchase on a business card is also permissible if it has a business purpose and the goods are booked. No documents — the expense is treated as the director's income, and the company pays for it as tax agent, including insurance contributions.

For an importer the conclusion is boring but useful: a business card is not the owner's wallet but a tool of the company's settlements. Every payment on it must leave a trace in the accounting, otherwise during an audit it will turn into personal income tax, a penalty and contributions. The court decision — in case A07-12164/2025, the card — on the arbitration courts website.

Source: Vremya bukhgaltera

← All posts

Report a bug
Report a bug

You can submit a bug report after registration — that way we can clarify the details and let you know when it is fixed.