Calcuta Calcuta
Customs Customs

Court backs customs: higher duties on goods brought in through the EAEU are lawful

The Moscow Region Arbitration Court for the first time upheld higher duties under Government Resolution No. 2240 on European perfumery imported via Kazakhstan, Armenia and Belarus; the amount in the Alkor i Co case must be recalculated.

3 min read Source: CentrVED

The Arbitration Court of the Moscow Region held lawful the additional assessment of higher duties on cosmetics and perfumery from unfriendly countries brought in through the EAEU (ЕАЭС): the Domodedovo Customs dispute with Alkor i Co LLC, which operates the L'Etoile chain, ended against the importer, case No. A41-41366/2026, pravo.ru reports. According to the outlet, this is the first case in which an increase in the duty on goods already cleared in the union has been recognised as lawful; both Forbes and the CentrVED channel call the ruling precedent-setting.

The ground for the assessment is Government Resolution No. 2240 of 7 December 2022 on import duty rates for certain goods, in its current wording of 21 September 2026. The higher rates, as the channel reports, are 15–50% and apply until the end of 2027, and in this dispute a 20% rate was applied to French perfumery instead of the usual 6.5%. The goods in the case were produced in France, Italy, Spain, Germany, Poland and the Czech Republic and were imported through Kazakhstan, Armenia and Belarus.

The company argued on two grounds: the products had already passed customs clearance in another union state and acquired EAEU product status, and a letter from the Federal Customs Service (FCS, ФТС России) of 26 January 2023 says that in such a case no top-up is required. The court, as pravo.ru recounts, separated customs status from country of origin: union product status does not exclude special economic measures, while the letter is the opinion of a particular official, not a normative act and not an official clarification. To the argument that carriage began before the list was amended, the court replied that the rate is taken at the date of import into Russia, and the importer should have weighed the risk of a regulatory change in its contracts.

On one point customs lost: it could not confirm the quantity and weight from which the payment was assessed, and the court ordered the amount recalculated; the company was refused in the rest. Lawyers from Denuo call the ruling a dangerous precedent: the court did not explain which norms allow a higher duty to be charged on goods released for free circulation in the union, and did not establish whether there was intent to circumvent, while, in their words, practice has not yet formed — an earlier similar dispute was resolved in the importer's favour.

What it means for your calculation

The duty now has to be computed from the country of origin and from the date of import into Russia, not from where the goods were cleared or which rate applied at shipment: if your model carries 6.5% as the conventional rate for perfumery and this case applies 20%, then the difference of 13.5 percentage points has to be looked at straight away, in the cost of the consignment, not in correspondence with customs two years later.

The second calculation is the size of the additional assessment itself: it rests on the quantity and weight that customs confirmed with documents, and it is exactly there that the ruling in the Alkor i Co case came apart into a recalculation. So, checking an additional assessment in your own future, first verify the base — from which consignments and from which lines of which declarations the kilograms and pieces were taken, because the amount can still be knocked down by calculation, whereas the rate, as the ruling shows, can no longer be.

Source: CentrVED

← All posts

Report a bug
Report a bug

You can submit a bug report after registration — that way we can clarify the details and let you know when it is fixed.