Calcuta Calcuta
Customs Customs

Court: fine and granular potassium chloride not comparable for customs value adjustment

The Ninth Arbitrazh Appeal Court ruled that using granular potassium chloride for comparison was unlawful when adjusting customs value of fine potassium chloride exports.

2 min read Source: law4ved

The Ninth Arbitrazh Appeal Court upheld OOO EuroChem-VolgaKaliy's claim against the Central Electronic Customs and overturned customs value adjustments on six export customs declarations for potassium chloride.

The company exported fine potassium chloride (second grade in five declarations, first grade in one). The customs authority rejected the declared transaction value and applied the residual method, comparing it with granular potassium chloride that the same exporter had previously supplied to the same buyer.

The court found fine and granular potassium chloride to be non-homogeneous goods, as they differ in form, moisture content, content of the active substance, production technology, use and storage conditions. These differences affect price, and the customs authority failed to prove commercial interchangeability. The court also noted that the granular product requires more complex processing, while second-grade fine potassium chloride has restrictions on storage and use.

The company justified the transaction price with industry quotations from Argus, Fertecon, CRU and Fertilizer Week for the 30 days before the price was agreed, provided an overview showing a discount of USD 20–25 per tonne for the non-standard product, and submitted calculations, tables and quality data. The customs authority rejected these documents without reasoned analysis, which the court found unlawful.

The court also rejected the claim of a relationship between the company and buyer FERTISTREAM DMCC: no such relationship was stated in the contested decisions as a ground for rejecting the first method, and the customs authority produced no evidence of ownership or control.

What it means for your calculation

Exporters must not merely point to a price difference — they need to substantiate product non-comparability with measurable characteristics such as grade, form, active substance content, moisture, particle size and intended use. If customs applies the residual method using a higher-priced product, its homogeneity must be refuted with evidence, and the transaction price must be supported by quotations for the period when the price was agreed, with an explanation of any discount applied.

Source: law4ved

← All posts

Report a bug
Report a bug

You can submit a bug report after registration — that way we can clarify the details and let you know when it is fixed.