Large buyers increasingly ask suppliers to sign a “tax clause”: a term under which the supplier compensates losses if its counterparty failed to pay taxes or to meet another tax duty, writes the lawyer Natalya Goryachaya. Legally it is a pair of instruments: assurances about circumstances under Article 431.2 of the Civil Code and indemnity for losses under Article 406.1, as EZh-Yurist reminds.
In the case reviewed, buyer I recovered RUB 1.4 million from supplier K. Clause 6 was built so that compensation followed if the supplier failed, within the agreed period, to remove the signs of an “unformed source” along the chain of transactions that put the buyer’s VAT deduction at risk, and K had given advance consent for the tax office to inform I about VAT gaps. The mechanics then ran themselves: K delivered sunflower seeds, I filed a return claiming the deduction, months later the inspectorate sent a letter about detected mismatches, I demanded the supplier close the gap, the supplier did not, and the buyer filed an amended VAT return and paid RUB 1.4 million to the budget. The pre-trial claim was ignored, and the case went to court.
The supplier held on to two objections. First, the buyer paid tax into the budget voluntarily, that is, gave up the deduction itself rather than being stripped of it. Second, an information letter is not a decision of the tax authority, and by itself it produces no tax consequences. The practice review on Garant walks through the same steps, and in the case discussed the court rejected both defences: nothing stops the parties from tying civil-law consequences to receiving such information from the inspectorate, provided the contract is signed and its terms agreed. The result — three instances for the buyer.
For a supplier the story yields three practical rules. Check what the clause treats as a breach: a letter from the inspectorate, a demand to close the gap, a decision on an assessment, or only an act that has entered into force. Do the money: if the clause is written as compensation for “losses”, it covers tax paid to the budget, penalties and the cost of an amended return, and the cure period is usually a few weeks, in which a gap cannot realistically be closed. And do not sign an assurance you have not verified: in this case the supplier guaranteed that it had handed the inspectorate consent to disclose tax secrecy, and that very sentence became the ground for recovery.
For a buyer the mirror is simple: the clause works only if the contract names the event, the amount and the procedure, otherwise a court sees not an obligation but a declaration of intent. Here the buyer was helped by linking the consequence to one concrete document — the information letter — and by not waiting for a decision after an audit: under the clause the signs of a gap are enough, if that is what the parties agreed.