Importers increasingly pay not the foreign seller itself but a third party the seller names, and that arrangement is not forbidden: case law shows that what decides the dispute is not the agreed recipient of the payment but the documents proving that the obligation to the seller was performed, points out customs-value consultant Valentina Ionicheva. Her review holds two cases with opposite outcomes: No. А41-112640/2025, where the court backed the declarant, and No. А51-6634/2024, where customs won.
In the first case the decision of 16 September 2026 records the essentials: the parties to the foreign-trade contract had agreed in advance that payment to third parties was allowed, and the recipients themselves were named directly in supplementary agreements to the contract. The court noted that a difference between the party shown on the invoice and the party that actually received the money does not by itself indicate an unreliable customs value and does not change the amount of the price paid for the goods. The conclusion for a declarant is plain: if the settlement order is agreed and the payments match the obligations under the contract, sending money to a third party is not on its own a ground to refuse method 1 — the transaction value of the imported goods.
In the second case the payment also went to a third party, a Turkish company, and the court sided with customs because the declarant never disclosed the recipient’s role. The documents did not show what functions that party performed in the settlements for the disputed delivery or how it related to the foreign seller. The court stressed that allowing payment to a third party does not release the declarant from the duty to substantiate the declared customs value, and a single payment order naming the recipient is not enough.
The frame of the dispute is always the same: paragraph 8 of Article 38 of the EAEU Customs Code forbids basing value on arbitrary or fictitious figures, while Article 39 permits the transaction-value method once the declarant has confirmed the terms of the deal and the fact of payment, as a court works through the similar case А40-26069/2025. When money goes past the seller, it is exactly the link “the fact of payment” that breaks most often: the funds left, while the connection between them and the debt to the seller is invisible on paper.
So the document set is assembled before release, not after a request from customs. Into the contract goes a term permitting payment to third parties, plus supplementary agreements naming the recipients directly. From the seller comes a letter instructing payment to a specific party, referring to the contract and the batch. From the pair “seller — recipient” come documents explaining the third party’s role: an agency agreement, a supply contract, a set-off or assignment agreement, correspondence. Payment orders carry the contract number in their payment purpose, and the seller confirms in writing that the obligation is performed and the goods are paid for. If the recipient withheld its own fee from the sum, that has to be laid out on paper separately: an agent’s remuneration folded into the price is precisely the case where the customs value is recomputed rather than the payment scheme being challenged.