Calcuta Calcuta
Public procurement Public procurement

Pipeline theft case: defence seeks legal assessment of Chinese plants

The defence in the case over the theft of more than RUB 500 million allotted for the Rostov-on-Don—Donetsk water pipeline has asked the head of the Investigative Committee and the prosecutor general to assess the Chinese plants' conduct.

4 min read Source: Kommersant

The lawyers of the defendants in the case over the theft of more than RUB 500 million allocated by the Russian Ministry of Defence to build a water pipeline from Rostov-on-Don to Donetsk have appealed to Alexander Bastrykin, head of the Investigative Committee (СКР), and to Prosecutor General Alexander Gutsan, asking for a legal assessment of the conduct of staff at the Chinese plants that supplied the fittings, Kommersant reported on 4 November 2026. The investigation considers the equipment defective; the defence points to the marking "GGG 50" cast on every valve — the German-standard designation of ductile iron — and to the factory quality documents that accompanied the delivery.

How the supply chain was built

The decision to organise an alternative water supply from Rostov-on-Don to Donetsk was taken in 2022, and the Ministry of Defence put the Military Construction Company (ВСК) in charge of laying the pipeline. According to the version of the Main Military Investigative Directorate of the Investigative Committee, within the state contract for the Don—Donbass pipeline the ВСК signed a supply agreement with LLC NEST (НЭСТ) for water valves worth RUB 533 million, and NEST brought LLC Interarm in as a subcontractor.

Interarm's executives — general director Vladimir Kuranov and his deputy Vilen Dallari — together with a representative of NEST are charged with fraud on an especially large scale and giving a bribe (Part 4 of Article 159 and Article 291 of the Criminal Code). The investigation holds that they artificially inflated the price of the works and saved on the quality of the metal, supplying products that did not meet the technical specification, after which bursts and leaks appeared in the pipeline. The damage was assessed at the full contract price. The case is heard by the Voroshilovsky District Court of the Rostov Region, in a closed session. RBC-Rostov reported that the case has reached court: following the preliminary hearing two of the accused were taken into custody and one more was placed under house arrest.

What the defence answers

Oleg Klimenko, counsel for Dallari, notes that the preliminary investigation sent the manufacturers in China not a single request — neither to clarify the marking nor to check the quality of the goods before they were shipped to the customer. The defendants had no criminal intent, in his words: they had no reason to distrust producers who had always supplied quality goods before, and the Russian companies could not run their own expertise — there was no suitable equipment, and the contracts did not provide for such a check.

The defence attributes the leaks not to defective valves but to poor installation carried out by another firm: the necessary supports were not put in place, "tons of metal were literally hanging in the air", and water hammer periodically knocked the valves out. The leaks are now eliminated and Donetsk receives water without interruption, the defence says.

The question of the Chinese suppliers has been running since autumn: on 28 September 2026 Kommersant described an advocate's request to the Russian Foreign Ministry for legal assistance — the defence needed the plant representatives to take part in the court session, and, if they refused to appear, to use their written answers instead. Requests have now been addressed to diplomatic agencies as well. If a Russian court returns a guilty verdict and grants the claim of the injured party — the Ministry of Defence — for RUB 517 million, the defence may try to shift that sum onto the Chinese suppliers.

The first sentence in the case

The Tverskoy District Court of Moscow has already sentenced one of the defendants in the same case — Sergey Lomakin, former general director of LLC Natsakharprom. According to the investigation, he took RUB 16 million from an employee of NEST, promising to pass it to the ВСК in exchange for help in concluding the contracts, and simply appropriated the money. After his detention he pleaded guilty and signed a pre-trial cooperation agreement with the Main Military Prosecutor's Office, within which he testified against the other defendants. Under the special procedure, for fraud the court imposed four years in a correctional colony.

What it means for your calculation

The injured party's claim is RUB 517 million against a supply contract of RUB 533 million: that is 97% of the contract sum, so the dispute is about practically the whole delivery, not about the share of defective items. The episode with the promised transfer to the ВСК — RUB 16 million, about 3% of the same sum — is the one that reached a sentence first: four years in a colony under the special procedure, against a claim that still has to be recovered.

For a buyer of equipment from China the conclusion is practical: in a dispute under a state contract the price at stake becomes the whole supply amount, not the price of the defective valves alone. That is why the cost of a batch should include proof of quality — marking on the body, factory protocols, an independent metal expertise at acceptance — the kind of evidence that can later be shown to a court. The fact that the contracts did not provide for such a check became an argument for the prosecution in this case, not for the defence.

Source: Kommersant

← All posts

Report a bug
Report a bug

You can submit a bug report after registration — that way we can clarify the details and let you know when it is fixed.