Calcuta Calcuta
Useful reads Public procurement

Government contract penalties: sanctions did not excuse delay

A supplier asked the court to write off penalties, citing sanctions and a foreign partner’s bankruptcy. Courts refused: sanctions are a business risk, and Rules No. 783 assume obligations left unperformed.

3 min read Source: ABM consult (Telegram)

A supplier brought equipment under a government contract late, the customer accrued penalties and went to court with them, and the supplier asked to have them written off: restrictive measures and the bankruptcy of a foreign counterparty had got in the way. The courts refused and recovered the penalty in full, and the ABM consult channel breaks down the case in the case card. The courts rejected the sanctions argument as a business risk: the restrictions were already in force when the supplier entered the purchase and signed the contract, so this is not something unforeseen.

The second argument, the bankruptcy of a foreign partner, fails for the same reason: the supplier answers for the actions of the subcontractors it drew in and guarantees the customer a delivery in the agreed time and in the agreed volume. The whole risk lies between it and its contractor, and it cannot be shifted onto the customer by pointing at a third party's default.

The courts also spelled out the "sanctions" ground for writing off a penalty. It sits in the Rules approved by Government of Russia Resolution No. 783 of 4 July 2018 and applies where obligations under a contract were not performed, including performed only in part. Here the goods were delivered, if late, so the ground does not open. On top of that the accrued penalty exceeded 20% of the contract price, which puts the case outside the automatic cases, and the courts found no other grounds unconnected with force majeure.

The Supreme Court gave another important clarification on these rules: in Ruling No. 305-ES23-20353 of 26 February 2024 it said that where the total of accrued and unpaid penalties does not exceed 5% of the contract price, the customer must write them off, and the contractor's disagreement with the accrual and a live court dispute do not stop a court from recognising the right to the write-off. It is useful in the other direction too: a review of Rules No. 783 recalls that there is no mechanical "under five percent, so write it off" while the main volume of obligations is unperformed, and that a write-off needs confirmed grounds and documents.

What it means for your calculation

The risk is counted before signing, not after a delay. The formula is plain: penalties on a contract grow for every day of delay, and their ratio to the contract price decides whether a write-off is even on the table. At 5% of the contract price the mandatory write-off under Rules No. 783 works, and beyond that limit, as in the case with 20%, there is no automatic write-off and a court has to look for another ground. So the estimate of a delivery from abroad carries: the lead time from the foreign supplier with a margin, the penalty accrued on that margin, and the cost of a failed purchase if the dates do not meet.

After that the paperwork of the subcontractor is counted. If the delivery date depends on a foreign counterparty, mirror liability for delay must sit in the contract with it, otherwise the gap between the penalty owed to the customer and what can really be recovered from the partner falls on the supplier. The partner's bankruptcy does not close that gap, nor does an appeal to force majeure: for a court, sanctions remain a risk accepted at the moment of signing the contract.

Source: ABM consult (Telegram)

← All posts

Report a bug
Report a bug

You can submit a bug report after registration — that way we can clarify the details and let you know when it is fixed.