The Moscow Arbitration Court recovered from the Central Electronic Customs (CET, Центральная электронная таможня) in favour of LLC YAVA RUB 1,142,258.51 in overpaid customs payments and penalties, as well as RUB 59,268 in state duty. The case concerns an adjustment of customs valuation when importing microwave ovens and electric kettles from China.
Customs did not accept the transaction value under the first method and applied the third or fallback method, citing the absence of several documents: a cost calculation, a certified bank control statement, a link between payments and invoices, and insufficient proof of delivery expenses.
The court found the customs arguments unfounded. A 180-day payment deferral does not cast doubt on the reliability of the transaction price. The link between payment and delivery can be established from a set of documents (contract, invoice, payment order, statement, bank control statement). An electronic bank control statement generated in a remote banking system does not lose evidentiary value due to the absence of a usual stamp and signature if customs has not proved it is unreliable.
A cost calculation is not a mandatory document if the seller refers to commercial secrecy and the other documents confirm the price and terms of the transaction. Transport expenses were confirmed by a forwarding contract, orders, invoices, universal transfer documents, payments and railway waybills; the forwarder’s explanations that remuneration was included in the cost of services were taken into account. Customs could not substantiate its claims regarding price lists.
The company defended its interests with a property claim for the return of overpaid amounts, and within that claim the court reviewed the legality of the customs valuation adjustment decisions.
For participants in foreign economic activity, the main point is that proof of customs valuation is built not from an isolated document but from a set of documents confirming the transaction price and expenses. The absence of a single document is not an automatic ground for refusal if it is compensated by other evidence.