The Dzerzhinsky District Court of Nizhny Tagil recovered more than RUB 800,000 from a city resident who imported 2 Mitsubishi Pajero and Lexus cars from Kazakhstan as if for personal use and soon resold them. Customs recalculated the recycling fee at the commercial rate.
In 2022, the man stated during clearance that he was importing the cars for personal use and paid the recycling fee at the preferential rate — RUB 3,400 for each. Both cars were sold to other persons, one almost immediately after import.
The Yekaterinburg Customs Office concluded that there were no grounds for the preferential rate because the cars were not used for personal purposes. The man claimed he bought them for his family and the sale was forced because registration was refused. The court rejected the arguments and ordered recovery of more than RUB 500,000 in unpaid recycling fee, over RUB 270,000 in penalties and a state fee — more than RUB 800,000 in total.
For participants in foreign economic activity, the conclusion is simple: the preferential recycling fee on import by an individual is possible only with actual personal use of the car. A short ownership period, sale to a third party and lack of actual personal use are factors by which customs and courts reclassify the purpose of import and charge the additional fee.