An importer of food additives from the Nizhny Novgorod region recovered 6.8 million rubles after a dispute over the VAT rate on an imported sugar substitute. The case was reported on November 5, 2026, by VED-OFF/ON and EastRussia, citing materials from the Far Eastern Transport Prosecutor’s Office.
During control of the sugar substitute shipment, Sakhalin Customs decided there were no grounds for the 10% preferential VAT rate and applied 20%. As a result, the declarant was charged an additional 6.8 million rubles in customs payments. The Far Eastern Customs Directorate upheld the decision, but prosecutors said customs authorities did not take into account the product’s intended use and properties, which affect eligibility for preferential taxation.
The transport prosecutor’s office filed a representation to the head of the Far Eastern Customs Directorate. The importer went to the Arbitration Court of Primorsky Krai, and a representative of the supervisory authority participated as a third party. The appellate instance found the customs decisions unlawful, and the collected funds were fully returned to the declarant.
For foreign trade participants, the case shows that in a dispute over a preferential VAT rate it is important to support not only the product code but also the product’s purpose, composition, and properties. If goods are used as food products or diabetic nutrition, supply documents, technical specifications, and a description of intended use may affect the assessment of the right to the benefit and the outcome of a customs or court review.
What matters in a preferential VAT dispute
10% preferential VAT rate — a reduced value-added tax rate applied to certain categories of goods if they meet the conditions of the Russian Tax Code and government-approved lists.
Declarant — the person who files a customs declaration and states information about goods, including the code, value, and applicable payments.
Customs control — customs verification of information about goods, documents, and import compliance, including correct classification and tax assessment.