Car owners can protect their rights against unlawful utilization fee reassessment, and Dmitry Khrulyov, vice-president of the International Mediators Association Power of Dialogue, gave a step-by-step algorithm of actions.
What to do immediately: record the date of receipt of the notice, up to twenty calendar days are given for payment, request the calculation, grounds for reassessment and details of the original payer, check the VIN, date and import scheme, as well as compliance with the three-year statute for detecting underpayment. Missing the twenty-day deadline does not deprive the right to dispute, but triggers penalties and possible collection. Compare the import date with the version of rules and the coefficient in force at that time, for cars from EAEU countries check whether the difference calculation between payments abroad and the amount payable in Russia is applied.
What documents to collect: sales contract, EPTS, customs documents, proof of payment, seller's advertisement and correspondence, this will help confirm the good faith of the purchase.
Non-judicial appeal: under Chapter 51 of Law No. 289-FZ, the deadline is three months from the day the owner learned of the violation, in the complaint ask to cancel the assessment or make a new calculation taking into account the proper payer and rules in force on the import date.
Negotiations with a mediator: you can offer the seller, car dealership and importer negotiations, the agreement will secure payment of the amount by the original payer, transfer of customs documents, reimbursement of expenses and joint participation in the proceedings.
Judicial protection: administrative claim with the possibility of preliminary security measures, the position of the Supreme Court in case No. 310-ЭС19-8382 allows a subsequent buyer to refer to the need to prove that he knew or should have known about the underpayment, the excessively paid amount can be refunded with interest, in case of winning the court costs are recovered from the customs authority, and the three-year statute for detecting underpayment limits the period for which the customs authority can reassess the fee.
Who it affects: owners of imported cars, buyers of used foreign cars, car dealers, importers, lawyers, and insurance companies. For calculating risks it is important to know that the utilization fee is calculated by the payer independently, and that in case of incorrect calculation the customs authority sends a notice of the need to pay, and if not paid within twenty days, the reassessed amount is collected in court with penalties for overdue payment.