Calcuta Calcuta
Customs Customs

Customs value: royalty inclusion procedure before first shipment

Russian case law 2026: disputes arise from failure to include royalties in customs value and from incorrect amount determination; in case A52-3880/2023 customs assessed about 295 mln rubles, courts recognized 67.98 percent of royalties.

2 min read Source: Valentina Ionicheva | Customs Value (Telegram)

Russian case law of 2026 again shows: disputes arise not only from failure to include royalties in customs value but also from incorrect determination of their amount.

In case No. A52-3880/2023, ruling of the AS North-Western District of 22.09.2026, customs assessed about 295 million rubles of customs payments in connection with failure to include royalties in customs value of raw materials and components for tire production. The courts considered that conditions for inclusion of royalty payments in customs value were met, but recognized inclusion of the entire amount as unlawful. The share of goods purchased within the EAEU amounted to 32.02 percent of the cost of finished products. Accordingly, the courts recognized inclusion of 67.98 percent of royalty payments into customs value of imported goods as justified.

In case No. A41-45088/2025, ruling of the AS Moscow District of 30.09.2026, the dispute concerned inclusion of a one-off royalty payment for know-how into customs value of components used in production in Russia. Courts of first instance and appellate instance supported the importer. However, cassation overturned the judicial acts and remanded the case for new consideration, indicating the need to study the interrelation of supply contracts for components, equipment and the licence agreement. The key question — could the buyer purchase imported goods without paying royalty payments. At the same time, absence of a direct indication in the contract on the need to pay royalties does not by itself exclude their inclusion in customs value. New consideration of the case is scheduled for 09.12.2026.

Who it affects: importers of raw materials, components and equipment with royalty payments, intellectual property right holders, customs representatives, and lawyers. For calculating customs risks it is important to know that only that part of royalty payments should be included in customs value which relates to specific imported goods, and absence of a direct indication in the contract does not exclude additional assessment.

Still before first shipments it is expedient: to analyze conditions of foreign trade and licence contracts, interrelation of deal parties; to determine which licence payments relate to imported goods and in what amount are subject to inclusion in customs value; to develop a documented procedure for calculation and allocation of licence payments between goods and shipments; to assess the possibility of applying deferred determination of customs value in accordance with the EAEU Board Council Decision of 19.06.2018 No. 103, if the exact amount of licence payments on the declaration date is unknown; if necessary, to consider obtaining a preliminary ruling on application of customs value determination methods. It is important to resolve these issues still at contract agreement stage, before first shipments, not after receipt of a customs authority request or after a customs audit.

Source: Valentina Ionicheva | Customs Value (Telegram)

← All posts

Report a bug
Report a bug

You can submit a bug report after registration — that way we can clarify the details and let you know when it is fixed.