Calcuta Calcuta
Useful reads Customs

Damaged or short-shipped import goods: how not to lose VAT

If imported goods arrive damaged or short-shipped, VAT has already been paid at customs. Without proper paperwork it will not be refunded, and tax authorities may assess VAT as on a gratuitous transfer.

3 min read Source: Bukhgalter.RF

Damage or short shipment in an import consignment is not unusual, and the main danger for the importer is not the defect itself but how it is documented. VAT on imports from countries outside the EAEU is paid at customs before the goods are released, so if part of the lot never arrived or was spoiled, the tax on it has already gone to the budget. It can be recovered only through an amendment of the customs declaration (ДТ) and a refund of overpaid VAT. If the paperwork is sloppy, customs will refuse, and the tax office may assess VAT as on a gratuitous transfer of goods.

There is no customs declaration for EAEU countries: VAT is payable no later than the 20th day of the month following acceptance of the goods for accounting. If the short shipment is discovered before that date, tax is paid only on the goods actually accepted. If later, the importer must file an amended indirect-tax return and an import statement, and restore the VAT on the short-shipped goods.

Regardless of the import route, the document set is the same. The importer prepares three documents: a primary discrepancy act on quantity (based on form ТОРГ-3), an internal act of partial acceptance of the goods actually received, and a claim letter to the seller. The seller must provide a letter acknowledging the short shipment and corrected invoices with VAT invoices confirming the actual value of the lot. If the seller refuses to acknowledge the problem, the goods can be written off as a shortage — but only with perfect paperwork: a spoilage act (form ТОРГ-16), a contract with a disposal company, landfill tickets, proof of storage conditions. Otherwise the tax authorities will treat the goods as transferred to third parties and assess VAT.

A separate risk is damage discovered after acceptance. In its letter of 3 March 2026 No. 03-07-08/16329, the Ministry of Finance clarified: if goods of inadequate quality are not used in VAT-taxable operations, the VAT paid at customs and claimed as a deduction must be restored under Article 170 of the Tax Code. The same applies to a short shipment discovered after VAT has been deducted: it is safer to restore the tax in the period of discovery.

Customs considers an application to amend the ДТ within 30 calendar days and either registers the amendment or refuses. Overpaid VAT is refunded by offset against advance payments, and an actual refund requires an application to the customs office at the place of tax registration.

The main recommendation is to provide in the contract for the procedure for documenting a short shipment in advance, before the cargo crosses the border. This saves weeks of correspondence with the seller and customs.

What it means for your calculation

VAT on imports is paid on the goods actually accepted, not on the seller's documents. A paperwork error costs more than the short shipment itself: restored tax plus additional assessments.

Source: Bukhgalter.RF

← All posts

Report a bug
Report a bug

You can submit a bug report after registration — that way we can clarify the details and let you know when it is fixed.