A company imported an electric train and declared it as a children's toy — 10% VAT. Customs demanded 20%, citing the Christmas design on the box and a tree-mounting bracket: in their view it was a festive decoration, not a toy.
The Arbitration Court of the Rostov Region (case No. А53-22568/2025) sided with the importer. The court held that the train assembles, runs and works without a tree; the instruction and the certificate of conformity confirm its play purpose. The Christmas design of the packaging, the court ruled, does not change the nature of the goods.
The ruling concerns more than this shipment. Toy importers, especially of seasonal items, face customs reclassifying goods as decorations because of seasonal packaging. Case No. А53-22568/2025 shows that a play purpose confirmed by documents outweighs the appearance of the packaging.
The 10 percentage-point VAT gap affects the cost of a shipment on import. For a toy importer, classification under the HS code (ТН ВЭД) directly affects the amount of customs payments.
What it means for your calculation
On import of toys the VAT rate depends on classification: 10% for toys, 20% for decorations. The court ruling confirms that a play purpose supported by the instruction and the certificate of conformity outweighs seasonal packaging.