An identification certificate is the document that determines the status of goods for export control purposes: whether they are controlled goods and technologies. For a foreign trade participant, this is not a formality — with an incorrect certificate, goods can be detained at the border and the deal can fall through.
A situation from practice: the certificate has already been obtained, and then new information appears — refined technical documentation, new product characteristics, advice from a more competent specialist, or a more detailed analysis of one's own. The expert organization's conclusions start raising doubts and then turn out to be incorrect.
What practice suggests: ask the expert organization to correct its conclusions based on a more thorough analysis of the documentation and information on the goods and the shipment, or to annul the certificate. But here a legal problem arises: neither correction nor annulment of an identification certificate is provided for by Government Decree No. 565 of 21 June 2016, which establishes the procedure for identifying controlled goods and technologies, including by expert organizations. In other words, the decree does not allow either correcting or revoking an already issued certificate.
Why this is dangerous at the border. Information about the certificate enters the customs authorities' information database almost immediately after it is issued by the expert organization. Customs authorities have no power to identify controlled goods for export control purposes — they rely on the information in the certificate. Therefore, when declaring the goods, the customs authority will proceed from the incorrect certificate that establishes the status of the goods under the law.
Consequences: clarifying the circumstances and obtaining a new certificate entail serious financial and time costs. The expert organization is responsible for the correctness of its conclusions in the certificate, but it does not answer for the time and financial costs at the border if the conclusions turn out to be wrong. In other words, the risks fall on the foreign trade participant.
How to minimize the risk before the examination: assemble the most complete set of documents and information on the goods and the shipment that affect whether the product is classified as controlled; establish a truly justified HS code of the EAEU (ТН ВЭД ЕАЭС) that matches the goods as precisely as possible, and, if necessary, obtain a customs classification decision. This lowers the likelihood that the expert organization will issue an incorrect certificate, unjustifiably relying on an HS code picked in haste.
Choosing an expert organization: approach it consciously, in favor of those who treat their work responsibly. In especially complex and disputed cases, turn to the Federal Service for Technical and Export Control (ФСТЭК России) for consultation or identification.
Legal basis: Federal Law No. 183-FZ "On Export Control", Article 24; Government Decree No. 565 of 21.06.2016. The certificate is kept for three years.