In November 2026, the Central Excise Customs (ЦАТ) cancelled a customs post's decision to amend the information declared in a customs declaration: the post adjusted the customs value using the fallback method, and the higher authority found it unlawful. The case started because the declared value was lower than the customs authorities' price information, and the post treated that as grounds to switch to the fallback method. ЦАТ reached a different conclusion: a lower declared value on its own does not prove that the value is unreliable.
This rule is set out in Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of Russia No. 49 of 26 November 2019: a price agreed by the parties cannot be rejected merely because the customs authority disagrees with its level compared with prices for identical or similar goods. A difference may indicate unreliability, but only if it is material and not eliminated during customs control.
The second conclusion concerns the fallback method. When applying it, the customs authority must comply with the requirements for comparability of goods and for the justification of the chosen source of price information. Information about goods that do not meet the established comparability criteria cannot serve as a proper basis for determining the customs value. In other words, a post may not take any data from its database and mechanically recalculate the value: the source must be comparable in terms of delivery conditions, period and characteristics of the goods.
The third conclusion concerns administrative appeal. An appeal to the higher customs authority does work if the legal position is well-built and supported by evidence. In this case the declarant submitted documents on the transaction, and the customs authority failed to prove grounds for refusing the first method.
What it means for the calculation is as follows. If a customs post added duty and VAT using the fallback method, and the only basis was the price difference, the importer has a chance to have the decision cancelled through an administrative appeal and to get back the overpaid amounts. But the burden of proof is documentary: contract, invoices, explanations of the economic reasons for the price, correspondence with the supplier. The fuller the evidence base, the higher the chance.
What it means for your calculation: an adjustment under the fallback method increases the base for duty and VAT; cancelling the decision returns what was paid. Check which source the post based the calculation on and whether it is comparable to your goods.