The appellate court upheld the ruling of the Arbitration Court of the Kaluga Region, which refused to refund customs payments to L'Oréal. The reassessment covers customs duty, VAT and penalties for late payment.
The dispute concerned including revenue from the sale of imported goods in their customs value (source). After the audit the company paid over RUB 658.8 million in duties and VAT and over RUB 236.9 million in penalties (source). The total reassessment came to RUB 895.8 million. The ruling may set a precedent for other importers of consumer goods that import with customs value reassessments. This is not the first audit of L'Oréal regarding customs value, and the company may appeal to the cassation court. The company may appeal to the cassation court if it disagrees with the appellate ruling.
The company challenged the reassessment, but courts of two instances did not support its claims.
Who is affected: L'Oréal, other importers of consumer goods, customs authorities and arbitration courts.