Calcuta Calcuta
Useful reads Economy

Constitutional Court: recycling fee increase cannot take effect earlier than a month after publication

The Constitutional Court in Resolution No. 42-P ruled that an increase in the recycling fee cannot take effect earlier than a month after publication, and the guarantees of Article 57 of the Constitution extend to all fiscal payments.

2 min read Source: FTL Advisers

The Constitutional Court of Russia in Resolution No. 42-P of 23 June 2026 recognized as unconstitutional paragraph 2 of Government Resolution No. 938 of 6 June 2023, which established a period of less than a month for the entry into force of an increase in the recycling fee. This decision is significant not only for the recycling fee, but for all non-codified payments.

The essence of the case: LLC “Terra Group” imported agricultural machinery from Kazakhstan on 30 June 2023. Resolution No. 938, increasing the recycling fee coefficients by more than four times, was published on 9 June and entered into force on 1 July 2023. The company submitted a fee calculation on 6 July at old rates — 4.3 million roubles, but customs demanded 17.5 million roubles at new coefficients.

The Constitutional Court established that the recycling fee, although formally not a tax, is by its legal nature an obligatory public fiscal payment. The guarantees of Article 57 of the Constitution of Russia apply to it, prohibiting an increase in payments without a reasonable period for the payer's adaptation. Since the legislation on the recycling fee lacks special rules for the entry into force of acts increasing its amount, the time limits of Article 5 of the Tax Code of Russia must apply — no earlier than one month from the date of official publication.

The Court emphasized that the guarantees of constitutional protection against the retroactive effect of laws increasing taxes and fees extend to all obligatory public payments of a fiscal nature, regardless of their formal sectoral classification. The recycling fee by its nature is an obligatory, individually gratuitous fiscal payment, close to taxes and excises.

The practical significance of the resolution extends far beyond the recycling fee. The legal position of the Constitutional Court may potentially be relevant for other obligatory non-tax payments, an increase in the amount of which leads to a significant increase in the fiscal burden on business. This concerns the technological fee, the environmental fee, the recycling fee and other non-codified payments.

For importers and manufacturers this means that when the amount of such payments is increased, the state is obliged to provide an adaptation period of at least one month. This reduces the risk of a sharp multiple increase in the fiscal burden on already completed imports and allows businesses to plan expenses in advance.

An analysis of the legal consequences of the resolution was published by “Pravo.ru” (source).

Source: FTL Advisers

← All posts

Report a bug
Report a bug

You can submit a bug report after registration — that way we can clarify the details and let you know when it is fixed.