The Arbitration Court of the Moscow Region for the first time recognized as lawful the additional assessment of increased duties on goods from “unfriendly” countries imported through the EAEU. The court supported the Domodedovo customs in a dispute with LLC “Alkor and Co”, which manages the “Letual” chain (case No. A41-41366/2026).
The company purchased cosmetics and perfumery produced in France, Italy, Spain, Germany, Poland and the Czech Republic through Kazakhstan, Armenia and Belarus. The goods passed customs clearance in these countries and received the status of EAEU goods, after which they were moved to Russia.
The court distinguished the customs status of the product and its country of origin. The status of an EAEU good does not exclude the application of special economic measures. European cosmetics and perfumery falls under increased rates, even if it has already been processed in another state of the union. The court called the FCS letter of 26 January 2023 the opinion of a specific official and did not recognize it as a normative act or official clarification.
The court also indicated that rates should be applied on the date of import into Russia, and the company should have taken into account the risk of changes in customs regulation when concluding contracts. In the end, the court recognized the increased duties as lawful, but found an error in one of the calculations — customs could not confirm the quantity and weight of the goods on which it charged the payment. The court ordered it to recalculate this amount.
For importers, this means that importing goods from unfriendly countries through the EAEU no longer guarantees duty-free movement, and this creates new risks for business, and this is important to take into account.
The EAEU Court should consider the question of compatibility of such additional charges with mutual recognition of customs decisions and Art. 29 of the EAEU Treaty. The advisory opinion is expected by the end of November 2026.
An overview of the situation was published by TKS (source).