Payment by proforma invoice and absence of an export declaration did not convince the court that the importer understated the price. The Thirteenth Arbitration Court of Appeal overturned the first-instance decision and supported LLC 'Shokolatye' in the dispute with the Kaliningrad Regional Customs, which did not accept the value, applied the reserve method and assessed an additional 378,344.42 rubles; the case analysis was published by the channel 'Disputes with customs'.
Cocoa butter for chocolate production was imported on FCA Tallinn terms, the transaction price was 348,800 US dollars, or 17.44 dollars per kilogram. Customs' first argument was a noticeable difference from another shipment, but when the price of the comparative goods was recalculated from pounds sterling to dollars it came to about 19.82 dollars per kilogram, and the appeal held that the difference alone does not prove a significant deviation: the other conditions of the compared transaction were not analysed in the customs decision.
Next the court examined the payment documents. The company transferred 100% prepayment through a payment agent, the agent's instruction mentioned a proforma invoice dated 16.04.2025, and the seller issued the final invoice on 25.04.2025, and customs doubted such a link. The court, however, established that the quantity, unit price, total value, seller, buyer and contract number matched in both documents, the reference to the proforma in the payment documents was explained by the fact that payment was made before shipment, and different numbers of the preliminary and final invoices do not mean the payment relates to another shipment.
Separately there was the export declaration. The actual sender KATOEN NATIE EESTI AS explained that the goods left a warehouse in a free customs zone and no declaration was filed; customs did not refute this explanation, and the court held: in such circumstances the absence of an export declaration and of value in the transit document does not prove the price is unreliable. There is a caveat in the decision — the conclusion refers to a specific supply scheme, not to releasing the importer from export documents in all cases.
Transport costs were also confirmed: an order agreement with the forwarder LLC 'Parmaz', road transport from Tallinn to Kaliningrad for 1,600 euros included in the customs value, a payment order. Customs demanded documents on the forwarder's relations with the actual carrier, the court replied that the importer had not concluded a direct contract with the carrier and the absence of these documents does not refute the confirmed cost of the forwarder's services; the absence of a price list did not become a basis for adjustment either.
The channel formulates the practical conclusion as checking links, not matching numbers: if the advance was paid by proforma — show how it relates to the final invoice, and if quantity or price changed, attach an explanation and calculation; if payment went through an agent — link the agency agreement, the instruction, the payment and the seller's specific invoice; if no export declaration was filed — obtain the sender's written explanation of the procedure applied; if a forwarder organised the transport — confirm the obligations by contract, order, invoice and payment and explain who performed the transport and why the contract with them is held by the forwarder.