On the claim of the East Siberian Transport Prosecutor's Office a court declared the Khabarovsk customs decision unlawful and cancelled a fine of 1 million roubles imposed on a foreign economic activity participant (FEA, ВЭД) for stating an incorrect vehicle value when declaring goods.
The error was a technical glitch in converting currency: when calculating customs value the company used the Chinese yuan instead of the US dollar, which distorted the information in the declaration. The FEA participant applied to customs in good time to withdraw the passenger customs declaration (PTD, ПТД), but customs nevertheless held the legal entity administratively liable and set a fine of 1 million roubles. Believing it had grounds for defence, the participant also sought support from the oversight body.
After the appeal to the East Siberian Transport Prosecutor's Office, prosecutors studied the circumstances and challenged the customs decision in court. The arbitrazh court — Russia's state commercial court — granted the prosecutor's claim, declaring the Khabarovsk customs decision unlawful and setting it aside, and the 1 million rouble fine was returned to the FEA participant.
The case shows in practice that timely recourse to an oversight body and consistent appeal in court protect business from unjustified measures of customs administration, even where a technical mistake in the declaration data was made in the first place.